| 2017 | | | |
| 2016 | | | |
| 2015 | | | |
| 2014 | | | |
| 2013 | | | |
| 2012 | TMI | | Daniel Trakas, Kirk Roose, Rodney Nixon, Alan Downey |
| 2011 | The Infield | | Don Gray, Jerome Wallman, Bayard Pelsor, Dutch Spiedel |
| 2010 | Test of Time | Buckeye-Columbus, Greater Central Ohio | |
| 2009 | Lightly Seasoned | | Joe Fraley, George Alcorn, Greg Batchelor, Darryl Flinn |
| 2008 | Over Easy | Buckeye-Columbus | |
| 2007 | Emeritus | Pittsburgh Metro | |
| 2006 | Picture This | Canton | |
| 2005 | Riverblend | Cincinnati Western Hills | |
| 2004 | Wishful Thinking | | |
| 2003 | Noteworthy | Greater Central Ohio | |
| 2002 | Montage | Cleveland East, Elyria | |
| 2001 | Cincinnati "Pops" | Cincinnati Western Hills | |
| 2000 | Cincinnati "Pops" | Cincinnati Western Hills | |
| 1999 | (not awarded) | | |
| 1998 | Cincinnati "Pops" | Cincinnati Western Hills | |
| 1997 | The Alumni | Greater Pittsburgh | Leo Sisk, George Kosak, Don Scheetz, Al Kolesar |
| 1996 | The Alumni | Greater Pittsburgh | Leo Sisk, George Kosak, Don Scheetz, Al Kolesar |
| 1995 | The Alumni | Greater Pittsburgh | Leo Sisk, George Kosak, Don Scheetz, Al Kolesar |
| 1994 | The Alumni | Greater Pittsburgh | Leo Sisk, George Kosak, Don Scheetz, Al Kolesar |
| 1993 | The Alumni | Greater Pittsburgh | Leo Sisk, George Kosak, Don Scheetz, Al Kolesar |
| 1992 | The Alumni | Greater Pittsburgh | Leo Sisk, George Kosak, Don Scheetz, Al Kolesar |
| 1991 | The Alumni | Greater Pittsburgh | Leo Sisk, George Kosak, Don Scheetz, Al Kolesar |
| 1990 | Moments Notice | Elyria | |
| 1989 | Backward Glance | Greater Pittsburgh & Upper Ohio Valley | |
| 1988 | Fourmation | Buckeye-Columbus | |
| 1987 | Fourmation | Buckeye-Columbus | |
| 1986 | Tall Timber | Cincinnati Western Hills | |
| 1985 | Harmony Supply Line | Cleveland West, Canton, Wayne County | |
| 1984 | Circle W Four | | |
| 1983 | Fourmation | | |
| 1982 | Notable Expressions | | |